|
The Forgotten Refugees:
Jews From Arab Lands
By ADA
AHARONI and ALAIN ALBAGLI It is inevitable that a Palestinian state will be established, if
only because the 1947 United Nations resolution establishing Israel also
established Palestine. The nature of this new state, the process of its
establishment and its eventual relation to Israel represent awesome
challenges. Peaceful relations between theses two states will not happen
unless there is grassroot reconciliation. But there cannot be grassroot
reconciliation unless past wrongs are acknowledged. One wrong that has been
ignored for far too long is the plight of Jews from Arab countries. Few political leaders in Israel or the Arab world acknowledge that
the number of Jews who were forced to leave Arab countries, 856,000,
surpassed the number of Palestinians who were ousted or fled the newly formed
State of Israel, 650,000. As almost half the Jewish citizens of Israel,
together with their descendants, are from Arab countries, any peace effort must,
of necessity, acknowledge this exodus. We suggest that to acknowledge the
story of the Jewish uprooting from Arab countries can facilitate
reconciliation, as it shows that there was forced migration and claims of
restitution on both sides. Jews from Arab countries are angry and hurt, and they object to a
reconciliation that does not include their own heritage and history. They
express their frustrations by voting for right-wing parties who promise them
recognition, although they are ideologically and traditionally neither
extreme right nor extreme left. Their intransigence toward their Palestinian
neighbors and the establishment of a Palestinian state is a touchstone in
reconciliation. Putting their claims in the balance could enhance the
promotion of the establishment of a Palestinian state. During the 1947 U.N. debates, the head of the
Egyptian delegation warned that "the lives of a million Jews in Muslim
countries will be jeopardized by the establishment of the Jewish state."
The chairman of the Palestine Arab Higher Executive, Haj Amin el-Husseini,
told that body: "If a Jewish state were established in Palestine, the
position of the Jews in the Arab countries would become very precarious...
Governments have always been unable to prevent mob excitement and
violence." Indeed, soon after partition, riots broke out throughout the
Arab world. Jewish homes, shops and synagogues were burned and looted;
hundreds of Jews were murdered, thousands were imprisoned and many were
deprived of their citizenship. Jews in Arab countries were confronted with a political and social
climate of unbearable hostility. Although many had been prestigious members
of their country of birth, they were removed from government agencies and
their admission to public office was severely restricted. They became hated
outcasts in their own land, terrorized, imprisoned and often banished. Where once Jewish communities flourished and thrived, as in Iraq
and Egypt, their traces have been erased, as they were compelled to leave and
abandon centuries of established culture and tradition. The outline of a lasting settlement ‹ or at least absence of
hostilities ‹ is becoming clearer. The vision includes a full Arab
recognition of Israel's legitimacy and not another colonial enterprise to be
tolerated momentarily like the Frankish kingdom of Jerusalem. Other
considerations include the establishment of a politically viable Palestinian
state, the rollback of Jewish settlements, the termination of Palestinian and
Arab incitement to hatred and terrorism, the full acceptance and integration
within Israeli society of its Arab citizens and the indemnification of
Palestinian and Jewish refugees. Because of deep-rooted mistrust, the comfort zone within which both
parties can negotiate is at present non-existent. Deep societal changes have
to occur before political leaders have room for negotiation. Regrettably, one
of the lapses in the Oslo process has been the absence of avenues for
reconciliation at the community level. Fortunately, both Palestinian and Jewish refugee communities are
familiar with Sulh, the Middle Eastern rituals of reconciliation . Sulh
rituals, used to resolve long-standing vendettas, incorporate cultural
elements and stress the link between the psychological and political dimensions
of reconciliation. It is high time that emphasis in the peace process be redirected to
community leaders and away from top-down conflict-resolution processes.
Community leaders in the civic, religious, education and media realms need to
assume their responsibility in pursuing reconciliation. They must acknowledge
explicitly the legitimacy of their opponent's claim and commit themselves to
rebuilding the image of the opponent. Espousing a perverted image of the
opponent even in the heat of debate negates efforts at acknowledging
legitimacy. Western support should be limited to those that pass this test. This reciprocal acknowledgement is the cornerstone
upon which future political leaders will be able to build a viable peace
process. Putting the claims of Jewish refugees from Arab countries into the
balance would encourage both populations to favor a two-state solution and
the election of pro-peace political leaders on both the Israeli and
Palestinian sides. In conclusion, a more objective and balanced approach
to the tragedies of both Jews from Arab countries and Palestinians could have
a moderating effect on both populations. Jews from Arab countries would have
their history and heritage restored and would become more open to a peaceful
arrangement. In turn, the Palestinians would realize that they are not the
only ones who have suffered, making them more prone to reconciliation. This
conciliatory effect could lead to a beneficial promotion of peace between
Israel and the Palestinians, and in the Middle East in general. Ada Aharoni is a professor of cultural sociology at the Technion Institute of Technology in Haifa and founder of the International Forum for the Culture of Peace. Alain Albagli is a consultant in international development and a freelance journalist. Both were born and raised in Egypt. |